Posted by Perfect Afternoon on

The Everything DiSC and Predictive Index (PI) Behavioral Assessment represent individualized methods for examining professional behaviors. The Everything DiSC model created by Wiley defines 12 workplace behaviors based on four foundational traits which include Dominance (D), Influence (i), Steadiness (S), and Conscientiousness (C).

Two team members discuss strategy

The Predictive Index evaluates four primary behavioral motivations which are Dominance, Extraversion, Patience, and Formality in addition to secondary aspects like Decision-Making and Response Level for understanding job suitability and workplace conduct. Both assessment tools evaluate behavioral patterns, but DiSC examines interpersonal relationships while PI targets the underlying motivational forces. This analysis examines the relationship between the 12 DiSC behavioral styles and PI’s behavioral framework.

Everything DiSC and Predictive Index (PI) Behavioral Assessment: Overview of Frameworks 

  • Everything DiSC: The highly visual circumplex model combines four fundamental styles to create 12 workplace behavioral profiles (D, Di, iD, i, iS, Si, S, SC, CS, C, CD, DC).
  • Predictive Index: The Predictive Index uses a 4-point graph to display four core drives—Dominance (need for control), Extraversion (social interaction), Patience (consistency), and Formality (structure).  This in turn create 17 reference profiles including Analyzer and Venturer, but it keeps the drives as the fundamental comparison points.

Everything DiSC and Predictive Index Comparative Analysis 

This analysis aligns DiSC’s 12 styles with PI’s four core drives by examining behavioral patterns. 

1. D (Dominance): Bold, results-oriented, decisive 

  • PI Drives: High Dominance, Low Patience 
  • Comparison: The assertive behavior of D matches PI’s Dominance drive which seeks control, but the D’s rapid pace is opposition to PI’s low Patience which shows a dislike for routine activities.

2. Di: Dynamic, persuasive, action-driven 

  • PI Drives: High Dominance, Moderate Extraversion 
  • Comparison: Di demonstrates leadership qualities through Dominance while their persuasive power reveals an underlying Extraverted nature.

3. iD: Enthusiastic, bold, outgoing 

  • PI Drives: High Extraversion, Moderate Dominance 
  • Comparison: A DiSC iD’s outgoing nature reflects their high Extraversion while their active approach stems from moderate Dominance.

4. i (Influence): Sociable, collaborative, inspiring 

  • PI Drives: High Extraversion, Low Dominance 
  • Comparison: Each focus on people working together emphasize the PI Extraversion’s social drive while Everything DISC focuses on lower Dominance shows they work well with others.

5. iS: Cheerful, supportive, empathetic 

  • PI Drives: High Extraversion, Moderate Patience 
  • Comparison: The DiSC iS exhibits warmth through Extraversion while PI’s Patience showcases their dependable supportiveness.

6. Si: Accommodating, patient, team-oriented 

  • PI Drives: High Patience, Moderate Extraversion 
  • Comparison: DiSC Si demonstrates peaceful teamwork through their Patience traits while PI’s Extraversion enhances their focus on working with others.

7. S (Steadiness): Calm, reliable, consistent 

  • PI Drives: High Patience, Low Extraversion 
  • Comparison: The Everything DiSC S maintains stability which parallels PI’s Patience aspect of consistency while low Extraversion demonstrates their reserved character traits.

8. SC: Reserved, methodical, stable 

  • PI Drives: High Patience, High Formality 
  • Comparison: DiSC SC type demonstrates reliability through Patience which is in alignment with structural focus of PI’s Formality’s rules.

9. CS: Cautious, precise, reflective 

  • PI Drives: High Formality, Moderate Patience 
  • Comparison: The precision of DiSC CS type aligns with PI’s Formality detail orientation while Patience reinforces their consistent approach.

10. C (Conscientiousness): Analytical, objective, meticulous 

  • PI Drives: High Formality, Low Extraversion 
  • Comparison: The detailed approach of a DiSC C type corresponds to PI’s Formality organized framework with their low Extraversion demonstrating a reserved concentration.

11. CD: Skeptical, determined, questioning 

  • PI Drives: High Dominance, High Formality 
  • Comparison: An Everything DiSC CD’s determination connects to PI’s Dominance and Formality which illustrates their analytical and organized method.

12. DC: Driven, perfectionistic, resolute 

  • PI Drives: High Dominance, High Formality 
  • Comparison: The Everything DiSC DC type demonstrates goal-focused behavior which corresponds to PI’s Dominance while the CD’s drive for perfection matches Formality’s precise nature.

Key Differences 

  • Focus: DiSC identifies behavioral traits (such as “i” for outgoing people) while PI evaluates motivational drivers (like Extraversion which causes sociability).
  • Structure: DiSC presents 12 styles that combine elements into distinct blends while PI uses four drives to generate a spectrum leading to 17 distinct profiles.
  • Application: DiSC examines interpersonal dynamics, but PI assesses only individual job suitability and performance prediction.

12 DiSC styles vs PI drives

The connection between the 12 DiSC styles and PI drives occurs when certain behaviors represent drives such as “D” and Dominance both involving control, but they show different underlying purposes. The DiSC model provides a behavioral framework and PI reveals underlying motivational factors. Combining them could enhance understanding: PI for role or job fit, DiSC for understanding the workplace interactions and how to improve them.